Ti West is a horror director who has caused mixed reactions. One youtube reviewer I'm fond of did a long video completely rubbishing his entire filmography. He's uncharacteristic of most horror directors in his consistent use of slow deliberate pacing. That being said, there's also been an element of fun (essential in horrror films!) particularly in his most recent films.
So now, having seen his earlier films "The Roost" and "Trigger Man", I'm finally up to date with his entire filmography and very much looking forward to his next full-length feature "In A Valley Of Violence" which is due to be released next year. (I'd be less interested in a short film, having not appreciated his absolutely dire contributions to some collaborative anthology movies in recent years.) "In A Valley Of Violence" is a revenge western movie with Karen Gillan, Taissa Farmiga (younger sister of Vera Farmiga) and John Travolta. Could be pretty awesome!
My ranking of Ti West's movies is after the two reviews.
The Roost (2005)
Ti West at his low budgetiest and slow burningliest ever. Still the interrupting sequences from Tom Noonan are brilliant and the threat when it arrives is appropriately effective. For that reason I'm not all that let down by the lack of decent characterisation.
This clearly isn't up with Ti West's other work, but it's not down with his contributions to anthology movies either. ("M is for Miscarriage" anyone?) This is a simple and moderately effective low budget effort with enough style to make it worth seeking out if you consider yourself a Ti West fan.
If Ti West's slow burn style aggravates you then you'll probably relegate this to the 9th circle of hell where physical torture is no longer effective and the demons have moved on to dredging out the last remnants of life and sanity from the remants of your weary soul. (I know some of Ti West's critics really hate his work that much.)
This is a simple, effective horror film, but not a mind-blowing experience by any means. The threat is generally off-screen somewhere. Either outside while they are inside or “over there”, but there’s a distinct charm to the low budget format.
The Roost is silly and the sections involving Tom Noonan ensure that we realise that this is intentional, but the rest of the film is sufficiently earnest to keep up an effective atmosphere.
B-
Trigger Man (2007)
This early film from Ti West mainly seems to be an opportunity for him to experiment. The pacing is slower than ever, even by Ti West standards and the way the camera zooms in and out serves to irritate rather than produce the intense atmosphere West is going for.
Early on there's a scene where the camera follows one character as he walks through a corner shop to buy a pack of cigarettes. Why are we shown this? No idea.
You can tell who the main character is going to be when the action finally kicks in because he's the only one who showed any genuine character traits before that point. This film has some seriously uninteresting characters.
Plenty of director's have initial dud films, but this one really feels like it was never intended for an audience beyond personal friends or potential employers. As an ultra low budget film with very limited scope, it's not utterly terrible. But as an indie film for wide release this is really dull.
D-
Ranking Ti West's Filmography
7. "M Is For Miscarriage" (segment from The ABCs Of Death) (2012)
One of the laziest short horror films I've ever seen. Someone goes to the toilet then realises there's blood in the toilet. - THE END! Good grief!
E-
6. Trigger Man (2007)
No characters, no story, no tension. An experiment in mood but without the story to go with it.
D-
5. "Second Honeymoon" (segment from V/H/S) (2012)
Another fairly lazy short film, it hints at something better on the way, but in the end it's a pretty dull stop-gap before other more interesting segments in the first "V/H/S" anthology movie.
D+
4. The Roost (2005)
A fun little by-the-numbers horror movie with the Ti West atmosphere making up for the lack of interesting characters. Very rough, but Tom Noonan hamming things up is quite a treat.
B-
3. House Of The Devil (2009)
Very slow-burn pacing, but done in a very interesting way. The real problem is that the ending doesn't quite justify the build-up. Still, this is a highly entertaining and super-creepy throwback to late 70s, early 80s horror films.
B+
2. The Sacrament (2013)
Some have complained that this is a little disrespectful of the real-life Jonestown massacre incident. But the fact is that cults are terrifying and Ti West intended this to be a horror movie without the use of the supernatural. I think he does a great job. The film draws us into a seemingly progressive community and then turns the tables dramatically.
A+
1. The Innkeepers (2011)
I'm a real sucker for horror comedies and with an awesome central performance from Sara Paxton, this is one of the funniest horror comedies I've seen. While Ti West's films are generally straightforward, I thought this was actually a little deeper than Ti West's other films. It doesn't surprise me that his follow-up would try to remove the supernatural altogether, since this is arguably a ghost film featuring no ghosts at all.
A+